For all he knew he'd survive his lesser snap. The fact thatStephen Strange could see behind the snap, when according to Doctor Strangea sorcerer cannot see beyond death, supports the idea that the snaps didn't really kill at all;the same theoryis also supported by a deleted scene fromAvengers: Endgame, in which the Ancient One said the Infinity Stones could not reverse death - but can still undo the snap. The audience witnessed the disappearance of fan-favorite heroes like Bucky Barnes, Black Panther, Groot, and Spider-Man, whose death was the most emotional of all, but why did they all turn to dust, instead of dying (like Vision)? (It then returns to a darker hue because Thanos' attack on the Avengers Compound kicks up a whole lot of dust in that local area.). Most likely he didn't want to risk Thanos getting hold of the stones again during the battle and chose to end it then and there. The only problem with his plan is that, according to Thanos, the beauty of his vision was that it was inherently random. This article contains mild. When Thanos is about to kill Iron Man, Dr. The "five years later" time jump is another five years after 2018, when the majority of the film is set, and the film explicitly says that 2014 was "nine years ago." The Marvel Cinematic Universe reached its peak with Avengers: Infinity War, which brought together all the current superheroes to stop Thanos from collecting all the Infinity Stones, and Avengers: Endgame, where the surviving heroes reversed the snap and defeated the Mad Titan once and for all. But the radiation's mostly gamma. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. How is it that in the Endgame Super Bowl TV spot everyone on Earth are mourning the dead if no one really died? How should I ask my new chair not to hire someone? The theory seems daring, and I have to say that it would undoubtedly fit Marvels misleading ways, but there are also plenty of holes. I could be totally wrong but I had to put this down somewhere and if I need to rethink it I'd rather be told than going around being an MCU idiot for the rest of my life Tony looks at Strange while he is windmilling the water or whatever, and Strange lifts up one finger. The important part of this insight, however, is that if Thanos always kept his word, then when he performed the Snap, he likely did indeed exempt Tony from it specifically since he had told Strange that he would spare Tony's life. What's the difference between Hulk's snap and Tony's then? There were other means available to the Illuminati of Earth-838, who defeated their Thanos with the Book of Vishanti, or perhaps that was an option after 15 million potential losses. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Avengers Endgame: Why No One Else Could've Done Iron Man's Snap Why does Tony have to snap Thanos and his army to death, wouldn't that create a massive paradox in the timeline because then the original snap wouldn't have happened and cause massive parallel timelines like the ancient one said it would..So why couldn't have Tony snapped Thanos back to original point in time with the knowledge that it will always happen that way making him..inevitable. This would also show why Thanos is different between the two movies, in the first movie Thanos is a lot calmer and more malevolent in his persueit of the stones almost like he knows he would collect them whereas the Thanos we see from 2014 in Endgame is more aggressive in his nature to get the stones due to the fact that's all he knows and is unaware of his success, again if he had been sent back to his original timeline knowing of his success and then death, that could be why he had no defences surrounding the planet (the garden) that he rested on and almost greeted the avengers and his own death as an old friend that was inevitable. What's the meaning (qualifications) of "machine" in GPL's "machine-readable source code"? Addressing the idea of reversing the snap, and why that is different to bringing back Black Widow, Marvel Studios co-president Louis D'Esposito explains that the Infinity Stones cannot reverse death. Dr. After his first snap, could Tony Stark or any of the Avengers use the Thanos more than likely saved Tony, and in doing so, in disrupting the gospel of chaos he had always espoused, Thanos doomed himself, and Strange was the architect of the whole thing. The lighting changes after the Hulk's snap, when Ant-Man looks at the birds, because that dust has been extracted again and used to reform Thanos' victims. For more information, please see our [Avengers Endgame] Marvel has punked us all: My long held theory and the KEY FACT that everyone has missed. "And you know, I think again, as a father, its very difficult to watch a character like that have to make a decision, knowing that he has to give up his life at the cost of his daughter losing a father and his wife losing a husband.". Starting the Prompt Design Site: A New Home in our Stack Exchange Neighborhood, Latest Blog Post: The First Officer: Alpha Protocol Book 2, Favorite Question and Answers from Second Quarter 2023. But after meeting up with his father in the past, it seems like he knows he wants to be the kind of man who put others before himself. It almost killed him. The MCU's first wave of films, collectively . But this is a second chance. Shockingly, Thanos proved to be the one villain who truly succeeded in his goal, and inAvengers: Endgame, he died content. - Quora Something went wrong. "[Tony chooses] to snap his finger and blip Thanos and his minions away to save the universe," she observes. During the scene where Hulk is about to snap, 2014 Nebula opens the portal prior to the Hulk snap. In the same kind of way, the snap appears to have deconstructed people right down to a molecular level. And it is clear that Doctor Strange means for Tony to die, and although Tony does not understand it immediately it seems to me that even the authours assume that he understands it when Strange tells him "if I tell you it won't happen". The word "blip" is the one Marvel used to refer to the snap inSpider-Man: Far From Home. Tom Bacon is Head of Screen Rant's Star Wars coverage. The Chitauri Leviathans are living beasts, so it makes sense, but the Outrider Dropships are clearly mechanical, as seen in Avengers: Infinity War.. We did not see this with the snap in Avengers: Infinity War, where. Ask Question Asked 2 years, 9 months ago Modified 2 years ago Viewed 3k times 5 In the movie scene, it seems to me that at the point when Tony snatches the stones off of Thanos' gauntlet, the situation was pretty much in control already. It had already been established that the Gauntlet can allow for all manner of nuance. Are you forgetting what had just happened before Tonys Snap? The truth is that this probably wasn't intentional; it's the kind of oversight that inevitably slips in when a franchise has been running for over a decade, albeit quite a dramatic example. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. But it also sounds like Thanos may not be his formidable selfthe Snap may have taken a serious physical toll on him, so its possible hes more easily dispatched when the OG Avengers finally catch up to him. The snap must have occurred in some way initially so that the remaining Avengers would go back in time, swap the Infinity Stones with fakes before they performed their snap that would eventually bring everyone back once Thanos is defeated. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. All Thanoss snap did was severely damage the Infinity Gauntlet and convince the Mad Titan that he had completed his lifes work. Any Don would love to have 100 Paulie Walnuts as his soldiers. He saved Tony cause anyone else snapping probably would have just killed team Thanos then you have a time problem. Doctor Strange, after all, focused only on events on Earth and Titan, meaning he'd have been unaware of what was happening in the distant corners of the cosmos. Why did Iron Man's snap in the end only killed Thanos and his - Quora Avengers: Infinity War saw Thanos snap his fingers and apparently kill half the life in the universe - but that may not have been the the case at all. Next: Infinity War's Biggest Question Is What Endgame DIDN'T Show, Avengers: Age of Ultron Foreshadowed Thor's Infinity War Failure, Those who vanished as a result of Thanos snap, Infinity War's Biggest Question Is What Endgame DIDN'T Show, Yellowstone's Kevin Costner Exit Drama Threatens To Destroy The Show's Ending, "Over The Moon": Chris Evans' Brother Recalls MCU Star's Sweet Reaction To His Barbie Casting. Thus this will involve both some time travel and universe hopping via the Quantum Realm as the place where all realities meet and use of a time vortex. Is there a way to use DNS to block access to my domain? Did Tony really kill Thanos : r/MCUTheories - Reddit He believed he fought on the side of life, but in truth he was a champion of death. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. It's entirely possible that, somewhere in the universe, some alien race had the ability to undo the snaps on a limited level - Doctor Strange wouldn't see that, because he was focused only on events on Earth and Titan. I didn't see it that way. One of the conditions of Tony's involvement in the Time Heist was that when they recovered all six Stones from the various timelines, there would be no alteration of the past five years so that his daughter's life would be protected. from FanTheories. His war is over. Although a couple of years passed since the snap that turned half the universe into dust, the consequences of this could still be felt, and they will surely continue to have an impact in upcoming films. Thanos literally erased half the life in the universe - not just sentient beings, but half the plants, animals, and bacteria as well. If you go back and watch Infinity War, when [Strange] says one, Benedict is just choked on emotion. 21 Redbeard_1776 1 yr. ago The only way this works is if Tony dies. He destabilized ecosystems across the entire universe, no doubt triggering environmental and ecological catastrophes, and depleted vital resources. And that logically raises the possibility that Thanos could return. In the end of the day it was Tony that wanted Bruce to snap everyone back and not change what had happened so why would Tony then go and change the past for another version of himself and not give the alternate version of himself the chance that he had. The theory suggests that beating Thanos is only possible by not interfering with his original plan and making sure he has all the Infinity Stones at his disposal. Why didn't Hulk's snap kill Thanos and his army? : r/marvelstudios - Reddit A graduate of Edge Hill University, Tom remains strongly connected with his alma mater as a volunteer chaplain. Why did Iron Man's snap in the end only killed Thanos and his army and not the others? Now, Marvel has further fuelled fan speculation with the publication ofThe Art of Marvel Studios' Avengers: Endgame, a book of concept art and exclusive interviews, which contains two important clues regarding what happened to Thanos at the end of Endgame. Why Thanos Didn't Just Kill All of the Avengers in Infinity War By Matt Lune Published Nov 12, 2018 There's a reason the Mad Titan didn't just wipe out his enemies in Avengers: Infinity War, and it makes a lot of sense. @NKCampbell That doesn't prove it, like I said he only suspects it might. It did something else. But in those timelines - and probably in the majority of those 14 million futures - Doctor Strange was never restored. As Thanos departs to retrieve the sixth and final Stone, Stark asks Strange why he made that choice, and the answer is interesting. I'd have to watch the magic chick explain alternate time lines to smart Hulk again but, as they say, you and the cap'n make it happen https://youtu.be/Vdm9J3zXw-Q Like Kevin Garnett, anything is possible https://youtu.be/Wcz_kDCBTBk. One theory is that the souls were transported to the Quantum Realm, explaining a mysterious flood of energy at the moment Thanos snapped his fingers. If he had not made that decision, had he gone for the kill, they wouldnt be in this situation. In reality, Thanos' snap doesn't make sense at all. He could've killed Thanos easily without giving his Advertisement Coins 0 coins Premium Powerups Explore He was waiting for the exact moment to use that high-tech pager. The way the heroes vanished in Avengers: Infinity War wasnt just made that way to make the audience cry theres a lot more to it, both in-universe and behind the scenes. His reasoning is simple: on a planet with too many people and limited resources, the survivors have more than they need, solving the world's problems. But according to the Ancient One, anyone who uses the Time Stone to explore the future will be unable to see past the moment of their death. No trace of Tony. Cookie Notice Film screener for the Austin Film Festival and holder of passionate opinions e.g. In the end of the day it was Tony that wanted Bruce to snap everyone back and not change what had happened so why would Tony then go and change the past for another version of himself and not give the alternate version of himself the chance that he had. The Blip - Wikipedia @Shreedhar What he means to say that Tony just had to hand over the stones Hulk who could snap again. Update crontab rules without overwriting or duplicating. Its likely similar things happened everywhere on Earth and other planets, meaning that people who have survived the snap may have been killed in the accidents the snap caused.